{"version":"1.0","generated_at":"2026-09-27T14:39:15.794799","id":2866,"slug":"two-year-university-study-finds-banning-ai-from-classrooms-leaves-students-worse-off","title":"两年大学研究发现：禁止课堂使用 AI 使学生表现更差","summary":"阿姆斯特丹自由大学法学教授 Thibault Schrepel 为期两年的实验显示，禁止使用 AI 的组连续两年排名最后；无指导 AI 组略高于禁 AI 组；结构化提示工程培训组第一年领先，但第二年优势几乎消失。研究者原本以为无指导使用 AI 弊大于利，最终承认“我错了”。","abstract":"两年大学研究发现：禁止课堂使用 AI 使学生表现更差 阿姆斯特丹自由大学法学教授 Thibault Schrepel 为期两年的实验显示，禁止使用 AI 的组连续两年排名最后；无指导 AI 组略高于禁 AI 组；结构化提示工程培训组第一年领先，但第二年优势几乎消失。研究者原本以为无指导使用 AI 弊大于利，最终承认“我错了”。 阿姆斯特丹自由大学法学教授 Thibault Schrepel 为期两年的实验显示，禁止使用 AI 的组连续两年排名最后；无指导 AI 组略高于禁 AI 组；结构化提示工程培训组第一年领先，但第二年优势几乎消失。研究者原本以为无指导使用 AI 弊大于利，最终承认“我错了”。 原贴提到：A law professor spent two years testing how an AI ban, unguided AI sugge 来源：the-decoder.com 一位法学教授花了两年时间测试禁止使用 AI、无指导的 AI 建议和结构化培训如何影响学生表现。不使用 AI 的小组连续两年排名最后。“我错了，”研究者写道。他曾假设没有指导的 AI 弊大于利。 阿姆斯特丹自由大学的 Thibault Schrepel 将他“AI 法律”课程的学生随机分成三组。所有人的任务相同：以四到五人的小组合作，他们有 20 分钟时间改进《欧盟人工智能法案》的一项条款。评分涵盖实质内容、清晰度、比例性和创新性。第一组不能使用 ChatGPT。第二组收到直接嵌入文本中的 ChatGPT 生成的修改建议，可以继续使用该工具，但没有关于如何使用它的指导。第三组接受了法律提示工程…","access_level":"member","access_label":"免费阅读","access_mode":"full","is_preview":false,"canonical_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/content/2866/two-year-university-study-finds-banning-ai-from-classrooms-leaves-students-worse-off","html_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/content/2866/two-year-university-study-finds-banning-ai-from-classrooms-leaves-students-worse-off","json_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/content/2866/two-year-university-study-finds-banning-ai-from-classrooms-leaves-students-worse-off.json","published_at":"2026-09-13T17:27:01","updated_at":"2026-09-27T14:03:15","category":{"slug":"ai-skills","name":"AI技能杠杆"},"source":{"site":"the-decoder.com","author":"Jonathan Kemper","url":"https://the-decoder.com/two-year-university-study-finds-banning-ai-from-classrooms-leaves-students-worse-off/"},"tags":["AI技能","AI政策","AI教育","AI治理","AI禁令","AI素养","ChatGPT","人机协作","学习效果","实验研究","提示工程","教育实验"],"topics":[{"slug":"agent-workflow","name":"Agent工作流","url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/topics/agent-workflow","reason":"这篇内容命中「Agent、工作流」等主题信号。"},{"slug":"ai-super-individual","name":"AI超级个体","url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/topics/ai-super-individual","reason":"这篇内容命中「技能、学习」等主题信号。"},{"slug":"ai-tools","name":"AI工具","url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/topics/ai-tools","reason":"这篇内容来自该专题长期覆盖的栏目。"}],"keywords":["AI技能杠杆","Agent工作流","AI超级个体","AI工具","工具","自动化","模型","Cursor","Claude","Agent","智能体","工作流"],"questions":[{"question":"两年大学研究发现：禁止课堂使用 AI 使学生表现更差主要讲什么？","answer":"阿姆斯特丹自由大学法学教授 Thibault Schrepel 为期两年的实验显示，禁止使用 AI 的组连续两年排名最后；无指导 AI 组略高于禁 AI 组；结构化提示工程培训组第一年领先，但第二年优势几乎消失。研究者原本以为无指导使用 AI 弊大于利，最终承认“我错了”。"},{"question":"这篇文章最值得关注的要点是什么？","answer":"阿姆斯特丹自由大学法学教授 Thibault Schrepel 为期两年的实验显示，禁止使用 AI 的组连续两年排名最后；无指导 AI 组略高于禁 AI 组；结构化提示工程培训组第一年领先，但第二年优势几乎消失。研究者原本以为无指导使用…；原贴提到：A law professor spent two years testing how an AI ban, unguided AI sugge；来源：the-decoder.com"},{"question":"这篇文章和哪些AI专题相关？","answer":"它适合放在Agent工作流、AI超级个体、AI工具专题里阅读。 关联原因：这篇内容命中「Agent、工作流」等主题信号。；这篇内容命中「技能、学习」等主题信号。；这篇内容来自该专题长期覆盖的栏目。"},{"question":"阅读这篇文章建议先理解哪些关键词？","answer":"建议先理解AI工具、工具、自动化、模型、Cursor这些关键词，再结合正文判断工具、机会或风险是否值得进入自己的工作流。"}],"terms":[{"slug":"ai-tools-term","name":"AI工具","definition":"在AI觉醒星球里，「AI工具」属于「AI工具」方向。围绕AI工具、模型能力、自动化流程和真实使用场景做整理，优先关注能提升效率、降低成本和创造新交付的工具。 不只看工具热度，更看它能不能进入真实流程。","topic_slug":"ai-tools","topic_name":"AI工具","topic_title":"AI工具：模型、插件、自动化与实战场景","topic_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/topics/ai-tools","topic_path":"/topics/ai-tools","url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/glossary/ai-tools-term","path":"/glossary/ai-tools-term","json_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/glossary/ai-tools-term.json"},{"slug":"tools","name":"工具","definition":"在AI觉醒星球里，「工具」属于「AI工具」方向。围绕AI工具、模型能力、自动化流程和真实使用场景做整理，优先关注能提升效率、降低成本和创造新交付的工具。 不只看工具热度，更看它能不能进入真实流程。","topic_slug":"ai-tools","topic_name":"AI工具","topic_title":"AI工具：模型、插件、自动化与实战场景","topic_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/topics/ai-tools","topic_path":"/topics/ai-tools","url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/glossary/tools","path":"/glossary/tools","json_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/glossary/tools.json"},{"slug":"automation","name":"自动化","definition":"在AI觉醒星球里，「自动化」属于「AI工具」方向。围绕AI工具、模型能力、自动化流程和真实使用场景做整理，优先关注能提升效率、降低成本和创造新交付的工具。 不只看工具热度，更看它能不能进入真实流程。","topic_slug":"ai-tools","topic_name":"AI工具","topic_title":"AI工具：模型、插件、自动化与实战场景","topic_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/topics/ai-tools","topic_path":"/topics/ai-tools","url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/glossary/automation","path":"/glossary/automation","json_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/glossary/automation.json"},{"slug":"ai-model","name":"模型","definition":"在AI觉醒星球里，「模型」属于「AI工具」方向。围绕AI工具、模型能力、自动化流程和真实使用场景做整理，优先关注能提升效率、降低成本和创造新交付的工具。 不只看工具热度，更看它能不能进入真实流程。","topic_slug":"ai-tools","topic_name":"AI工具","topic_title":"AI工具：模型、插件、自动化与实战场景","topic_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/topics/ai-tools","topic_path":"/topics/ai-tools","url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/glossary/ai-model","path":"/glossary/ai-model","json_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/glossary/ai-model.json"},{"slug":"cursor","name":"Cursor","definition":"在AI觉醒星球里，「Cursor」属于「AI工具」方向。围绕AI工具、模型能力、自动化流程和真实使用场景做整理，优先关注能提升效率、降低成本和创造新交付的工具。 不只看工具热度，更看它能不能进入真实流程。","topic_slug":"ai-tools","topic_name":"AI工具","topic_title":"AI工具：模型、插件、自动化与实战场景","topic_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/topics/ai-tools","topic_path":"/topics/ai-tools","url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/glossary/cursor","path":"/glossary/cursor","json_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/glossary/cursor.json"},{"slug":"claude","name":"Claude","definition":"在AI觉醒星球里，「Claude」属于「AI工具」方向。围绕AI工具、模型能力、自动化流程和真实使用场景做整理，优先关注能提升效率、降低成本和创造新交付的工具。 不只看工具热度，更看它能不能进入真实流程。","topic_slug":"ai-tools","topic_name":"AI工具","topic_title":"AI工具：模型、插件、自动化与实战场景","topic_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/topics/ai-tools","topic_path":"/topics/ai-tools","url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/glossary/claude","path":"/glossary/claude","json_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/glossary/claude.json"},{"slug":"agent","name":"Agent","definition":"在AI觉醒星球里，「Agent」属于「Agent工作流」方向。聚合Agent、AI编程、Claude Code、Cursor、工作流自动化等内容，帮助你把智能体能力落到真实任务链路。 把智能体当成任务系统，而不是聊天窗口。","topic_slug":"agent-workflow","topic_name":"Agent工作流","topic_title":"Agent工作流：智能体、AI编程与自动化协作","topic_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/topics/agent-workflow","topic_path":"/topics/agent-workflow","url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/glossary/agent","path":"/glossary/agent","json_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/glossary/agent.json"},{"slug":"ai-agent","name":"智能体","definition":"在AI觉醒星球里，「智能体」属于「Agent工作流」方向。聚合Agent、AI编程、Claude Code、Cursor、工作流自动化等内容，帮助你把智能体能力落到真实任务链路。 把智能体当成任务系统，而不是聊天窗口。","topic_slug":"agent-workflow","topic_name":"Agent工作流","topic_title":"Agent工作流：智能体、AI编程与自动化协作","topic_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/topics/agent-workflow","topic_path":"/topics/agent-workflow","url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/glossary/ai-agent","path":"/glossary/ai-agent","json_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/glossary/ai-agent.json"}],"preview_hidden_sections":[],"related_items":[{"id":3094,"title":"研究发现：有 AI 可用时，人们几乎完全不愿说“我不知道”","url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/content/3094/ai-access-makes-people-almost-entirely-unwilling-to-say-i-don-t-know-study-finds","summary":"一项包含 5 个实验、3,132 名参与者的研究显示，只要能向 AI 求助，人们几乎不再说“我不知道”。在研究者刻意挑选的、模型几乎总是答错的电影细节题上，参与者的信心升到约 2.5 倍（75.9 对 29.6，满分 100），正确率却从 27.6% 降到 10.0%；合并所有研究，有 AI 时正确率 9.2%，无…","access_level":"member"},{"id":3081,"title":"Arena：GPT-6 Sol（Max）以 +7.7% 净改进重塑 Agent Arena Pareto 前沿","url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/content/3081/arena-gpt-6-sol-max-7-7-agent-arena-pareto","summary":"Arena 宣布 OpenAI 的 GPT-6 Sol（Max）进入 Agent Arena，基于 4K+ 真实智能体会话取得 +7.7% 净改进，排名第 6，中位成本 $0.75/task。榜单同时给出得分与成本两个维度，读者可据此判断该模型在性价比坐标上的位置。","access_level":"member"},{"id":3105,"title":"趋势解读：Meta's Muse agent gives every user a full，解读最新 AI 进展","url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/content/3105/meta-s-muse-agent-gives-every-user-a-full-cloud-computer-running-ubuntu-linux","summary":"趋势解读：Meta's Muse agent gives every user a full，解读最新 AI 进展：这条内容属于AI 技能与工作流，核心焦点是解读最新 AI 进展，适合继续追踪它对内容生产、业务执行和工具工作流的直接影响。","access_level":"member"}],"usage_policy":{"summarizable":true,"preferred_url":"https://opc.beizhux.com/content/2866/two-year-university-study-finds-banning-ai-from-classrooms-leaves-students-worse-off","private_fields_excluded":true}}